FPF.Reference:16.5.4.2 - Compare proposed ways to meet the need

Preface node heading:fpf-reference-16-5-4-2-compare-proposed-ways-to-meet-the-need:1568

What this page is

This is generated FPF reference text from the specification preface or supporting sections. It helps interpret FPF; it is not FPF Reference product documentation.

Methodology

Use it to understand how the specification wants to be read, then return to a route, pattern, or work packet for active work. Cite generated IDs only when the wording changes the task decision.

Content

The nightly windows require 56 hours of coverage per week. Qualified members of the internal team have 12 hours available without conflicting with their other assignments. No night assignment has been established. Even if the owner assigns those 12 hours and verifies the required response, another 44 hours still need staff.

Assume an external provider offers all 56 hours for 600 units per week, within a budget of 800. The proposed service includes a qualified operator and replacement coverage. For the declared incident class, its proposed serial bounds are 0.5 minutes for alarm delivery, 1 minute for the operator to take responsibility for the incident, 1.5 minutes for diagnosis and 1 minute to start mitigation. Their sum is 4 minutes. These are offer terms to verify, not observed performance.

The existing automation can route an alarm but cannot select and start the required mitigation within its current authorized function. A day-only promise would be cheaper, but the stated receiving use requires night coverage. These are consequential reasons for rejecting those alternatives in this case.

Alternative under the stipulated factsResult of comparisonWhat could change that result
Extend the internal rosterStaff have 12 hours available. The proposed roster has no identified staff for the other 44 hours.Assignments, replacement, response capability and the full cost of covering all 56 hours
Obtain the offered external provisionOffered price is within the budget and the proposed response bound meets the target; total cost and operating conditions remain to qualifySetup and continuing owner work, unavailable replacement, failed access, a failed bound or unacceptable contractual conditions
Use the present automation aloneMissing the required diagnosis and mitigation capabilityA separately developed and authorized capability with suitable assurance
Restrict the promise to daytimeDoes not meet the stated receiving useAn authorized revision of that need and its accepted consequences

Continuing the current arrangements leaves night coverage unverified. To assess a full internal roster, identify who could cover the other 44 hours, on what assignments and at what cost. To assess the external offer, qualify its total cost, terms and operating conditions. If a comparison is due, a second provider or a mixed roster could also supply a credible alternative. If the commission is to secure coverage and one qualified offer suffices, the owner can proceed within the purchasing authority. The parties must agree on terms and verify actual provision before anyone can rely on night coverage.


Last Updated: 2026-11-22 — upstream FPF commit 7a93d8f8 (github.com/ailev/FPF)