A.6.C:5 — Archetypal Grounding (Tell–Show–Show)
Preface node
heading:a-6-c-5-archetypal-grounding-tell-show-show:16229
What this page is
This is generated FPF reference text from the specification preface or supporting sections. It helps interpret FPF; it is not FPF Reference product documentation.
Methodology
Use it to understand how the specification wants to be read, then return to a route, pattern, or work packet for active work. Cite generated IDs only when the wording changes the task decision.
Content
A.6.C:5.1 — Tell
When boundary contract-language leaves a consequential ambiguity, recover the claim and referent, then answer only the live questions below. Keep ordinary metonymy when its capable participant and relation are locally recoverable; a literal act or individual commitment needs that participant and the governing conditions.
- What was promised? State the promise-content claim if one exists.
- What was said, published, or instituted? Identify only the asserted speech act, description/publication objects and institutional effects, under the conditions in §4.1.
- What governance or permission-looking claim exists? State either a generic D prescription with its normative source and applicability, an individual D claim about an obtaining commitment with its actual bearer and institution basis, or the selected
A6-AW-*claim in its own quadrant. State responsibility separately under its admitted domain predicate or return its missing governor. - What happened, what followed, and what supports reliance? State dated Work, each current result/change/delivery/acceptance claim, and each current evidence-use or reliance claim separately; omit absent claims.
When acceptance or the work still due depends on how undertakings, conditions or acts fit together, use §4.1 to establish the required connection. This includes one order with several required acts. Identify what was accepted and what remains open or due.
When those answers need stable reuse, decision, audit, dispute, or cross-face projection, write them in the one A.6.B Claim Register: one atomic statement, direct object, subject assertion, non-semantic pattern locator, and quadrant per row. Otherwise stop with the repaired atomic prose. Faces cite reused claim IDs or canonical locations; they do not create another bundle record.
A.6.C:5.2 — Show (System archetypes)
(A) Software API boundary
Draft wording:
“The Payments API guarantees idempotency. Clients must provide Idempotency-Key. We log all requests. Availability is 99.9%.”
Source clauses and additional illustrative premises:
Preserve “We log all requests”; the draft supplies no particular logging Work or observation basis. “Availability is 99.9%” does not say whether 99.9% is a target, a promised bound, or an observed value; that meaning remains unresolved.
For the extended case below, assume the PaymentsAPI description/publication, definitions of idempotency and key uniqueness, a gate policy with an additional key-validity condition, and a generic provider-side idempotency prescription. These are additional case premises, not atoms recovered from the draft. The source's client requirement remains to provide Idempotency-Key.
-
Description/publication: signature or mechanism publication for
PaymentsAPI(MVPK faces: TechCard, InteropCard). -
L: define idempotency and the uniqueness semantics of
Idempotency-Key. (“Idempotent” is a semantic property, not a duty.) -
A: admissibility predicate: request is admissible iff
Idempotency-Keyis present and valid. (Gate belongs to mechanism.) -
D: the API policy generically requires covered clients to provide
Idempotency-Key. In this extended case it also states a provider-side idempotency prescription. No individual commitment follows from those clauses alone. If the case claims thatClientIntegrator-AorProviderSystem-Abears one of those duties, cite that bearer's separately instituted A.2.8 commitment. (Responsibility, if claimed, needs its own direct relation.) -
E — additional hypothetical evaluation: suppose admitted system
PaymentsAvailabilityEvaluator-AperformedAvailabilityEvaluation-Payments-T1 : U.Workover the Payments API request population and windowTusing the availability metric stipulated for this evaluation.A.6.1 application
PaymentsAvailabilityApplication-T1has result bindingavailabilityResult -> AvailabilityResult-Payments-T1; that C.2.1 result episteme statesobservedAvailability=99.9%forT.When the SLA decision relies on this result, an A.10 path links it to the request-log and measurement carriers used. This hypothetical observation does not select the meaning of the draft's unlabeled 99.9%.
(B) Hardware interface boundary
Draft wording: “The connector guarantees safe operation. Devices must not exceed 20V. Negotiation must succeed before power is applied.”
Source requirements and additional illustrative premises:
The draft leaves open whether “Devices must not exceed 20V” is a device-behavior constraint or an obligation on a capable bearer, and it does not identify the safe-operation predicate. Preserve the 20V upper bound and the requirement that negotiation succeed before power is applied. The additional gate and test below do not resolve the bearer or safety choices.
-
Description/publication — additional case premise: assume a published interface spec supplying the pinout, electrical ranges, handshake procedure, and the test declaration used below.
-
L: electrical invariants and allowable ranges are definitions and invariants (truth-conditional).
-
A — additional gate premise: suppose the interface specification makes power delivery admissible only after the handshake state reaches an agreed mode.
-
Requirement awaiting classification: retain “Devices must not exceed 20V”; recover its constraint or duty-bearer reading before assigning it to L or D. The negotiation-before-power requirement remains distinct from the additional gate predicate.
-
E — additional hypothetical test: suppose admitted system
HardwareTestSystem-AperformedConnectorSafetyEvaluation-T1 : U.WorkoverConnector-C1under the declared method, load, and temperature window.A.6.1 application
ConnectorSafetyApplication-T1has result bindingsafetyResult -> ConnectorSafetyResult-T1; that C.2.1 result episteme statesmaximumObservedVoltage=19.8V,handshakeState=agreed-before-power, andConnectorSafetyCriterion-v3=satisfiedfor those conditions.When relied on, an A.10 path links this result to
TestReport-C1-T1,VoltageTrace-C1-T1, andNegotiationLog-C1-T1carriers.In this hypothetical test, 19.8V is below the retained 20V upper bound. The separately given criterion result does not by itself settle the draft's unspecified safe-operation claim.
(B-PER) Compact permission replay (only when the permission branch is live)
Situation: “ReleaseAuthoritySystem, acting as release grantor under assignment ReleaseGrantor-A, approved DeploymentAgent-A, acting under assignment Operator-A, to deploy Release-4711 after preflight.”
Unpack + classify:
-
Promise content (optional):
SVC-RELEASE-4711states which release artifact eligible consumers are promised. -
Speech-act Work:
ReleaseGrantorAssignmentis a declaredU.SystemRoleAssignmentspecies. OccurrenceReleaseGrantor-Ahas admitted SystemReleaseAuthoritySystemas holder and the local release-grantor kind as assigned-kind value. That System performs datedApproveoccurrenceSA-4711under the assignment.The assignment supplies only the holder and assigned-kind facts used by the policy. Any authority required by
ReleaseGrantPolicymust obtain independently.Under the applicable policy,
SA-4711institutes—not merely publishes—grant occurrencePER-4711only if the A.2.8.PER obtaining conditions hold. -
D — current grant (
A6-AW-NORM-GRANT):ReleaseOperatorAssignmentis another declared species. OccurrenceOperator-Ahas admitted SystemDeploymentAgent-Aas holder and covers this window. The grant's beneficiary participant cites that occurrence, and its permitted-action participant isU.EpistemeRef(Deploy-Release-4711).This Claim Register row uses
U.RelationRef(PER-4711), constrained toGrantedPermissionRelation@Context, as itsdirectObjectDesignation.SA-4711, the two assignments, policy, context, scope, and window remain grounds or qualifiers.The model may use this D claim only while the A.2.8.PER conditions make
PER-4711obtain and the row cites the named occurrence, act, and policy. -
E — weak evaluation alternative (
A6-AW-WEAK): if the basis establishes only current absence of prohibition in a sufficiently complete frame, recordNonProhibitionFinding@Context; do not promote it to a strong grant or place it in D. -
A — independent entry predicate (
A6-AW-GATE): “deployment is admissible iffPER-4711currently obtains and preflight is green” is anA-*predicate. It may consume the grant as one condition but is neither the grant nor proof of gate passage. If an actual gate decision is also asserted, record its A.21GateDecisionResult, bounded action, applicable profile application, complete required check-application result set, decision value, and consequence as a separate E claim. -
E — actual Work and exercise (
A6-AW-EXERCISE): A.13 first recovers admitted SystemDeploymentAgent-Aas the performer through obtaining assignment occurrenceOperator-Aof declared speciesReleaseOperatorAssignment; A.15.1 independently admits datedU.WorkoccurrenceDeployRun-4711. Because this permission-exercise branch expressly consumes precise assignment-bound attribution, F.6 then relates that already admitted Work through the same assignment and checks holder equality and coverage.The Work must instantiate the action specification inside the grant's scope and window. Only then may
PermissionExerciseRelation@ContextbindWorkRef(DeployRun-4711)toU.RelationRef(PER-4711), constrained toGrantedPermissionRelation@Context. The assignment contributes the beneficiary and attribution facts consumed here.Missing or failed F.6 alone leaves independently admitted Work intact but blocks this attribution-dependent exercise branch. If the same finding questions a premise consumed by A.13 or A.15.1 admission, recheck that premise and its dependent claims. Planned work, the approval wording, and preflight alone are not exercise.
-
E — optional result or delivery: if
DeployRun-4711returnsReleaseArtifact-4711, cite the A.6.1 result binding or an already governed subject-specificWorkResultRelation; if that artifact is transferred, cite the independently obtaining delivery/transfer relation defined by its subject pattern. -
E — evidence (optional): an A.10 path may link the grant, Work, exercise, result, or delivery claim to its current carriers for one bounded reliance use.
A.6.C:5.3 — Show (Episteme archetypes)
(C) Multiparty protocol boundary (behavioural and session-type motif)
Draft wording: “The protocol guarantees progress. Participants must follow the sequence.”
Source clauses and additional illustrative premises:
The progress guarantee needs its semantic or operational meaning. For the illustrative case below, assume the published protocol description and the trace-admissibility criteria; the named trace evaluation is an additional hypothetical case.
-
Description/publication: protocol description (could be a type spec or protocol spec plus explanatory views).
-
L — when the guarantee is semantic: the progress property is a law over the protocol model (truth-conditional, within the theory).
-
A — additional entry-condition premise: suppose a session-entry mechanism uses the declared trace criteria to determine whether an interaction may enter the session. Its entry predicate is A; the trace-validity definition remains L and an actual conformance verdict is E.
-
D: the protocol description generically requires covered participants to follow the stated sequence. It asserts no individual commitment occurrence.
-
E — additional hypothetical trace evaluation, not inferred from the progress guarantee: suppose admitted system
ProtocolConformanceEvaluator-AperformedProtocolConformanceRun-T1 : U.Workover bounded interactionTrace-42.A.6.1 application
ProtocolConformanceApplication-T1has result bindingconformanceResult -> ProtocolConformanceResult-T1; that C.2.1 result episteme statesconformanceVerdict=passandobservedTerminalState=completedunderProtocolConformanceCriterion-v5.For a disputed interaction, an A.10 path links this result to
MessageTrace-42,ConformanceRunRecord-T1, andProtocolAuditRecord-42carriers.
(D) Socio-technical “SLA + audit trail” boundary
Draft wording: “Provider shall respond within 4 hours for Severity‑1 incidents. Only Severity‑1 is covered. Evidence is provided by ticket logs.”
Unpack + classify:
-
Promise content (service promise clause, when present): a responsiveness promise for a defined incident class and window is separate from the SLA's generic prescription.
-
Description/publication: SLA publication (and its views for different audiences).
-
Scope from the source: the promise covers only Severity-1 incidents. This coverage restriction becomes an A claim only when a separately defined admission rule uses it as an entry or continuation condition for a named action or application.
-
D: the SLA clause generically requires the covered Provider to respond within 4 hours for Severity-1 incidents; only Severity-1 is covered. Claim that actual provider
ProviderSystem-Abears the four-hour duty only after the SLA's individualizing rule and required actual basis establish one A.2.8 commitment; otherwise keep the clause generic. -
Evidence source clause: the draft names ticket logs as evidence; it supplies no measured response interval.
-
E — additional hypothetical response evaluation: suppose admitted system
SLAEvaluator-AperformedResponseEvaluation-Ticket-17 : U.Workover Severity-1 ticketTicket-17under the declared clock and measurement method.A.6.1 application
ResponseMeasurementApplication-Ticket-17has result bindingresponseIntervalResult -> ResponseIntervalResult-Ticket-17; that C.2.1 result episteme statesobservedResponseInterval=3h42mandwithinFourHourTarget=true.When the SLA decision relies on this result, an A.10 path links it to ticket, response-timestamp, clock-source, and severity-classification carriers. The four-hour requirement is from the source;
3h42mis the additional hypothetical observation.
Last Updated: 2026-11-22 — upstream FPF commit 7a93d8f8 (github.com/ailev/FPF)