A.6.B:6 — Cross‑quadrant link discipline

Preface node heading:a-6-b-6-cross-quadrant-link-discipline:15395

What this page is

This is generated FPF reference text from the specification preface or supporting sections. It helps interpret FPF; it is not FPF Reference product documentation.

Methodology

Use it to understand how the specification wants to be read, then return to a route, pattern, or work packet for active work. Cite generated IDs only when the wording changes the task decision.

Content

The square also makes dependencies between claims inspectable. A material dependency MUST be explicit by claim ID or canonical location.

A.6.B:6.1 — Explicit reference rule

If a claim’s meaning materially depends on another L/A/D/E-classified claim, that dependency MUST be represented as an explicit reference to its ID or canonical location. A faithful restatement may explain the referenced content; it does not define an alternative rule.

A reader can then follow the explanation back to its governing claim and reconsider dependent uses when that claim changes.

A.6.B:6.2 — Canonical cross‑quadrant dependency patterns

These patterns are valid (and common). The square becomes operational when these links are used systematically.

(D → A) Prescription-or-duty-to-gate linkage

When governance says that a gate must be satisfied or enforced:

  • generic D-*: “Policy-P requires covered subjects to satisfy or enforce A-*”; or
  • individual D-*: “Actual bearer S has commitment C to satisfy or enforce A-*.”

This separates what is admissible (A) from generic normative content and any separately instituted individual duty (D). If responsibility is also claimed, state its admitted direct domain predicate or missing governor rather than inferring it from the duty.

(E → A) Evidence-for-gate linkage

When a claim reports actual observability of a gate decision:

  • E-*: “For the stated rejection or acceptance due to A-*, carrier C was produced or observed under conditions …”

This separates gate semantics (A) from the actual observation or result (E). A prescription to produce or retain a carrier belongs in D; an expectation or plan alone supplies no actual E result.

(D → E) Prescription-or-duty-to-evidence linkage

When governance prescribes evidence production, retention, exposure, or a measured property and a separate E-* claim states the related result:

  • generic D-*: “Policy-P requires covered subjects to retain or expose carrier class C used by E-* …”; or
  • individual D-*: “Actual bearer S has commitment CMT to meet the criterion evaluated by E-* under the stated exclusions …”

This separates a generic prescription or individual duty (D) from its adjudication (E).

(A/E → L) Semantic grounding linkage

When a gate predicate or measurement relies on definitions or invariants:

  • A-* / E-* references L-* that define terms or metrics.

This prevents “metric drift” and “definition drift” across views.

(D → L) Governance-to-definition linkage

When a generic prescription or individual obligation relies on precise term or metric meanings:

  • D-* references L-* that define the terms or metrics it uses.

This keeps governance text from accidentally redefining semantics in prose.

(A → D/E) Normative or evaluated input to a gate

When entry depends on a current grant or a separately established finding, reference that D or E claim and state how its subject enters the predicate. For example, A-CAL-01 in §8.4.5.4 requires the grant stated by D-CAL-01 to cover the plan and time, together with the required conflict finding. The grant, finding and entry decision retain their own obtaining conditions. A changed input reopens the admission evaluation that consumed it.

A.6.B:6.3 — The “triangle decomposition” for mixed sentences

Normative rule (decomposition). A conforming boundary text SHALL decompose any mixed sentence into its claim jobs. Recover the predicate and modality of an observability clause before assigning its quadrant. The triangle applies when the source states all three:

  • A: admissibility predicate (A-*)
  • D: generic prescription or individual-duty claim referencing the gate (D-* → A-*)
  • E: actual observation or result referencing the gate, with carriers when needed (E-* → A-*)

Keep a prescription or individually instituted duty to produce evidence in D. Preserve an expectation or plan as such; leave the actual E result absent until its basis exists. This repairs mixed validity, authorization, compliance, audit, and security claims without adding an unsupported third claim.

A.6.B:6.4 — Ground each dependency

Reusable laws retain their declared meaning, while an admission predicate can consume a normative position or an evaluated result. For each material link, state what it supplies: meaning, an input condition, an evaluation target or evidence support. Settle each depended-on claim under its own rule.

These are cross-quadrant restrictions. They do not prohibit same-quadrant references, such as L-* → L-* or E-* → E-*.

Normative rule (dependency grounds).

  • L-* claims MUST NOT depend on or reference A-*, D-*, or E-* claims (except for purely informative notes marked informative).
  • An A-* claim MAY reference a D-* claim for the normative content, duty or grant used by its entry predicate, and an E-* claim for a separately established finding or observation. It MUST identify the input and required scope or currentness under §5.2; deciding that entry is permitted requires the predicate to be satisfied. A-* may reference L-* for defined terms or invariants.
  • An E-* claim MAY reference a D-* claim as its evidence target or to identify the norm, duty, or grant used by its evaluation. The E-* result MUST satisfy its own predicate and the actual-work, evaluation, or observation requirements of §5.4; the D-* claim alone establishes no result or compliance. (E-* may also reference A-* for conditioning and L-* for metric or term meanings.)
  • D-* claims MAY reference L-*, A-*, and E-* claims when needed, and SHOULD do so by ID or canonical location rather than restating content.

Rationale (informative). The L restriction keeps the reusable definition or law independent of a particular gate application, deontic claim or observation. Expose a varying policy or state as a declared parameter; bind it where the condition or claim uses it.

A and D may refer to one another for different reasons: a duty can require enforcing a gate, while that gate consumes a separately obtaining grant. Examine those reasons rather than treating every reference as one ordering relation. A grant justified only by a gate result that itself assumes that grant would leave both claims ungrounded.

Evidence and results may report on normative claims or evaluate conduct against them under their own predicates.


Last Updated: 2026-11-22 — upstream FPF commit 7a93d8f8 (github.com/ailev/FPF)