A.2.9:4.3 — SpeechActRef discipline (normative)
Preface node
heading:a-2-9-4-3-speechactref-discipline-normative:9374
What this page is
This is generated FPF reference text from the specification preface or supporting sections. It helps interpret FPF; it is not FPF Reference product documentation.
Methodology
Use it to understand how the specification wants to be read, then return to a route, pattern, or work packet for active work. Cite generated IDs only when the wording changes the task decision.
Content
A SpeechActRef resolves to one actual Work individual admitted as SA : U.SpeechAct. It never denotes the kind itself or a SpeechActRecord.
-
If an A.2.8 commitment predicate or assertion cites this occurrence as its instituting basis, the referenced occurrence MUST satisfy occurrence-side SA‑C0…SA‑C3a. Citing the act in the obtaining predicate identifies the required world-side basis; it does not itself require a record. A receiving judgement that relies on this occurrence, including a commitment or grant judgement, gate, audit, or provenance claim, additionally needs the record and evidence basis in SA‑C4. It needs SA‑C6 only when its inference crosses local taxonomies, schemes, or policies.
-
A
SpeechActRefMUST NOT be replaced by anEpistemeRef(“see the document”) when occurrence provenance is needed. ASpeechActRecordor utterance-description episteme may make claims about the occurrence but is not the act. -
If a source cannot yet establish A.15.1 admission for one actual occurrence, it may create a separate
U.Epistemeidentified as a candidate observation stub. The stub is not aSpeechActRecord, supplies noSpeechActReforspeechActOccurrenceRef, and does not conform to the complete declaration schema or SA-C0. It carries a source-local candidate locator or C.2.1ClaimAddress, known observation claims, provenance for those claims, and explicit unknowns.If the actual
enactsMethod -> U.Methodrelation cannot yet be recovered, record that unresolved claim and its source-gap provenance in the stub; do not invent aU.MethodDescriptionto establish the missing Method relation. The stub supports no gate or deontic provenance and remains observation-only. After A.15.1 independently admits one exact actual occurrence, create a distinct conformantSpeechActRecord; do not promote or relabel the stub in place, though a separately governed provenance or evidence relation may cite it.
Last Updated: 2026-11-22 — upstream FPF commit 7a93d8f8 (github.com/ailev/FPF)